When may people end a political relationship, and who gets a voice in the separation?
Your job
You'll write a pretend legal filing to end a political relationship: the colonies' relationship with Great Britain. It's July 1776. No real court had the power to settle this, so your settlement terms are imagined. Don't present a later treaty as something already agreed.
Learning target: I can use grievances to argue for independence, answer a counterclaim, and evaluate a proposed settlement's effect on others.
Step 1
Read & Investigate
The rules of political separation
Each highlighter collects evidence for a different part of the filing. Pick one, then tap a sentence. Tap it again to clear it.
A
The argument for ending a government
In July 1776, Congress explained why the colonies sought independence. The Declaration argued that people have rights and that governments receive legitimate power from the consent of the governed. It claimed that people may change or abolish a government that destroys those purposes. Its authors wrote it to justify their decision and to win support at home and abroad.
B
Complaints in the Declaration
The Declaration listed grievances against the king. It charged that “He has dissolved Representative Houses repeatedly.” It charged that “He has kept among us, in times of peace, Standing Armies without the Consent of our legislatures.” It condemned him “For cutting off our Trade with all parts of the world” and “For imposing Taxes on us without our Consent.” Each complaint was about who had the right to govern the colonies.
C
Responsibility and disputed facts
The Declaration aimed its accusations at King George III, but Parliament passed the tax and trade laws, including the Stamp Act and the Coercive Acts. Patriot writers blamed the king to make a stronger case for breaking away. Many colonists, including Loyalists, rejected these charges.
D
A British defense
In the Declaratory Act of 1766, Parliament stated that it could make laws for the colonies “in all cases whatsoever.” British officials pointed out that Britain had spent heavily to defend the colonies in the French and Indian War. They treated the destruction of property, like the tea dumped in Boston Harbor, as an attack on lawful government. Many Patriots answered that Parliament could not tax colonists without their consent. Some in Britain, including Edmund Burke in Parliament, urged a compromise with the colonies.
E
Money and the frontier
A separation would raise difficult questions about debt, trade, property, and borders. Britain had debts from imperial war and defense; colonial governments and Congress also faced costs from the conflict. Deciding who owed what would require negotiation, not simply dividing a single shared bank account. Western lands were homelands of Indigenous nations. Britain and the colonies could claim authority, but their claims did not erase Indigenous governments or give either side an uncontested right to divide the land.
F
People outside the main argument
Loyalists opposed independence for many reasons and feared losing their property or safety. In November 1775, Virginia's royal governor, Lord Dunmore, promised freedom to enslaved people who escaped Patriot owners and joined British forces. Neither side promised freedom to all enslaved people. Women organized boycotts of British goods but could not vote or hold office. Breaking away from Britain could change who ruled while leaving many unequal relationships in place.
Legitimate
justified or accepted as rightful
Grievance
a complaint about injustice
Sovereignty
authority to govern
Settlement
proposed terms for resolving a dispute
Discuss with your partner, then jot your answer
Step 2
Draft the filing
About 450–600 words · reasoning matters more than length
Cite the readings like this: (B) or (B–C). You can use short phrases in the boxes, but explain every link to the evidence.
Before an Imagined Tribunal of Nations
No court in 1776 had authority to settle this dispute.
The Colonies, supporters of colonial independence represented by Congress,
Applicant,v.Great Britain, the British imperial government,
Respondent.
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
Case No. 1776-07
Complaint for Political Separation and Proposed Settlement
Fictional filing dated July 1776
Part 1 · The Complaint
Three grievances, each tied to a rule or right.
The request
In 2–3 sentences, state the political relationship you want to end and the principle that justifies ending it. Don't claim that everyone living in the colonies supported the applicant.
Part 2 · Proposed Settlement
Imagined terms, not historical outcomes. For each term, say who gains, who bears a cost, and whose agreement is needed.
Part 3 · Britain Responds
Imagined response based on evidence
6–8 sentences as the British government. Answer two specific grievances with arguments about imperial authority or defense. Accept, reject, or revise one settlement term and explain why. Use at least two evidence references. Acknowledge one reasonable colonial concern.
Part 4 · The Historian Comments
3–4 sentences. Explain one strength and one limit of comparing independence to a divorce. Does a justified demand for independence make the proposed division of land or political power fair? Use one detail from E or F.
Respectfully submitted, July 1776
Challenge (optional)
Add a short objection to your settlement from an Indigenous government or a Loyalist family, based on evidence. You can write it in the third person ("A Loyalist family would object that…") instead of speaking as them.
Step 3
Check & file
Print or save as PDF, or copy into your assignment
How you'll be scored
Criterion
3 points
2 points
1 or 0
Accuracy & sourcing
Three accurate grievances; four useful references
Mostly accurate; two or three useful references
1: major confusion or thin evidence; 0: absent
Rules & reasoning
Links grievances to principles; explains settlement costs
Links some claims; terms partly explained
1: mostly demands; 0: no reasoning
Multiple perspectives
Fair British counterclaims and meaningful excluded voices
Both present, but one is thin
1: caricature or missing view; 0: neither
Completion & analogy
All sections; clear limits of the analogy
One component weak or missing
1: several gaps; 0: no product
Score out of 12. You're graded on accuracy, evidence, and reasoning, not on whether you favor independence.