When is it fair to break away from a government, and who should get a say?
Your job
When two people end a marriage, one files papers in court. The papers list complaints and a plan for splitting things up. You will write pretend papers for the colonies breaking up with Great Britain. It is July 1776.
I can use evidence to explain why the colonies wanted to leave and who else should get a say.
Step 1
Read & Highlight
To do
A
A reason to break away
In July 1776, Congress approved the Declaration of Independence. It said all people have rights. It said a government gets its power from the people it rules. If a government takes away people's rights, the people can change it or get rid of it. The writers wanted to explain their choice to leave. They also wanted other people and other countries to support them.
B
The colonies' complaints
The Declaration listed complaints against King George III. It said “He has dissolved Representative Houses repeatedly.” That means he shut down the colonies' own lawmakers. It said he kept soldiers in the colonies in peacetime without their permission. It also blamed him “For imposing Taxes on us without our Consent.” Each complaint was about who had the right to rule the colonies.
C
Who made the rules?
The Declaration blamed the king. But Parliament, Britain's lawmakers, passed the tax laws. Parliament passed the Stamp Act. It also passed the laws that punished Boston. Patriots blamed the king because it made a stronger case for leaving. Not every colonist agreed with the complaints. Loyalists wanted to stay part of Britain.
D
Britain's side
In 1766, Parliament said it could make laws for the colonies “in all cases whatsoever.” That means in every way. British leaders said Britain had spent a lot of money protecting the colonies in the French and Indian War. They said dumping tea in Boston Harbor was breaking the law. Some people in Britain, like Edmund Burke, wanted Britain to make peace with the colonies.
E
Money and land
Breaking away would leave hard questions. Who would pay the war debts? What would happen to trade? Who would get the land in the West? That land was the home of Indigenous nations. They had their own leaders. Britain and the colonies both said they controlled it. But neither side had the right to split it up without the nations who lived there.
F
People left out
Loyalists wanted to stay with Britain. Many were afraid of losing their homes or getting hurt. In November 1775, Lord Dunmore, a British governor in Virginia, made a promise. He promised freedom to enslaved people who escaped Patriot owners and joined the British army. Neither side promised freedom to all enslaved people. Women helped by refusing to buy British goods. But women could not vote.
Grievance
a complaint about something unfair
Parliament
the group that made laws for Britain
Loyalist
a colonist who wanted to stay with Britain
Settlement
a plan to end an argument
Answer two questions
Step 2
Fill out the papers
To do
Before an Imagined Court of Nations
No real court could decide this in 1776.
The Colonies,
Filing side,v.Great Britain,
Other side.
)
)
)
)
)
)
Case No. 1776-07
Request to Break Away and Plan to Split
Pretend papers dated July 1776
Part 1 · What the colonies want
The request
The colonies want to break away from Great Britain because ___ (A).
Part 2 · The plan to split
This is your idea, not what really happened.
Part 3 · Britain answers
Write as if you are Great Britain.
Part 4 · A historian's note
Signed, July 1776
Step 3
Check & turn in
How you'll be scored
Skill
3
2
1
Facts
Complaints are correct and from the readings
One small mistake
Many mistakes
Evidence
4 or more paragraph letters
2 or 3 letters
1 or none
Other sides
Britain's answer is fair; left-out groups get a say
One of these is thin
Both are missing
Papers
Every part done
One part missing
Many parts missing
Out of 12. You are graded on facts and evidence, not on which side you pick.