How should we judge leaders who fought for liberty but did not protect everyone equally?
Your job
A performance review compares an employee's goals, actions, and results, then lets the employee respond. Your employee is the Second Continental Congress. You're a reviewer in July 1776, so you can only use what was known by then. No later victories count.
Congress's president chaired the meetings. That isn't the same job as the later President of the United States. You're reviewing Congress as a leadership team.
Learning target: I can evaluate congressional decisions using stated goals, historical evidence, and more than one group's perspective.
Step 1
Read & Investigate
What did Congress accomplish by July 1776?
Each highlighter collects evidence for a different part of the review. Pick one, then tap a sentence. Tap it again to clear it. Sending a petition is an action; whether peace came of it is the outcome.
A
A leadership team during war
The Second Continental Congress began meeting in Philadelphia in May 1775, after fighting at Lexington and Concord. Delegates had to coordinate resistance among colonies with different interests. Some still hoped to repair the relationship with Britain. Others moved toward independence. Congress was not elected by all the people living in the colonies; women, enslaved people, and many other residents had no direct voice in choosing its delegates.
B
Organizing a common defense
In June 1775, Congress established the Continental Army and chose George Washington to command it. Bringing forces under a shared commander helped coordinate resistance. Creating an army, however, did not guarantee military success, reliable supplies, or agreement among all colonists. As of July 1776, the war was still being fought.
C
Attempting reconciliation
In July 1775, Congress sent the Olive Branch Petition, written mainly by John Dickinson, asking the king to help restore peace. At the same time, Congress was supporting armed resistance. King George III refused to receive the petition. In August 1775, he declared the colonies to be in open rebellion.
D
Changing the goal
By 1776, support for independence had grown. Thomas Paine's Common Sense argued against monarchy and urged separation. On July 2, Congress approved the resolution for independence; on July 4, it adopted the Declaration explaining the decision. Congress offered a public argument that governments should protect rights and depend on the consent of the governed. Declaring independence did not make Britain recognize it.
E
Whose interests were protected
The Declaration did not abolish slavery or establish equal political participation for women. It also described Indigenous peoples in hostile terms rather than recognizing them as equal political partners. Colonial leaders could agree on independence without agreeing to share wealth or political power inside the colonies. Before 1776, enslaved people in Massachusetts had already petitioned for their freedom using the language of natural rights.
F
A historical disagreement
Some historians argue that influential colonists used a shared national cause to build support while keeping much of their own power. Other historians stress the risks delegates took: in British eyes, declaring independence was treason. The Declaration's claims about rights also gave excluded people words they could use to demand more.
These criteria are standards for judging Congress. Congress didn't explicitly promise all of them. Rate the result, not the effort: a sincere attempt that failed can still be "not met."
Continental Congress · Philadelphia
Leadership Performance Review
CONFIDENTIAL Form PR-1776 · Rev. July 1776
EmployeeSecond Continental Congress
Review windowMay 1775 – July 1776
Reviewer—
RoleIndependent reviewer
Rating key3 Met2 Partly met1 Not met
Part 1
Goals and results
For each criterion: pick a rating, the paragraph that proves it, and explain using a specific action or outcome.
Part 2
Overall assessment
4–5 sentences. Name the strongest accomplishment and the most serious limitation. Does success at coordination outweigh limited inclusion, or do you reject that tradeoff? Cite paragraphs like (B) or (D–E).
Part 3
Areas for improvement
Two goals Congress should pursue next. These are your recommendations, not what it actually did. Keep them realistic: Congress could debate, petition, coordinate, and urge colonies to act, but it didn't have the powers of a later federal government.
Goal 1
Goal 2
Part 4
Employee response
5–6 sentences in Congress's voice, starting with "We acknowledge…" Defend one decision with evidence, admit one real limitation, and answer a criticism from your review. Don't invent quotations or use later events.
Imagined rebuttal based on evidence
Reviewer signature · July 1776
for the CongressEmployee acknowledgment
Challenge (optional)
Write two overall ratings using the same facts: one from a Patriot merchant and one from a person excluded from political rights. Explain why identical facts can lead to different judgments. Write about each perspective in the third person ("A merchant would…").
Step 3
Check & turn in
Print or save as PDF, or copy into your assignment
How you'll be scored
Criterion
3 points
2 points
1 or 0
Historical accuracy
Keeps dates, roles, and outcomes accurate
Minor error; main account sound
1: major error or hindsight; 0: absent
Evidence
Four useful paragraph references support judgments
Two or three useful references
1: little support; 0: none
Evaluation
Explains criteria and considers effectiveness and inclusion
Judges both, but unevenly
1: mostly praise or blame; 0: no judgment
Completion & rebuttal
Four ratings, overall review, two goals, responsive rebuttal
One component weak or missing
1: several gaps; 0: no product
Score out of 12. A low rating and a high rating can both earn full credit when evidence and reasoning back them up.