Genre Swap · Lens: Big Ideas · May 1775–July 1776 G
Congress Performance Review
Did the Second Continental Congress do a good job?
Your job
At work, a boss writes a review to say what an employee did well and what they need to fix. You are the boss. The employee is Congress. It is July 1776, so you can only use things that happened by then.
I can judge Congress using evidence about what worked, what failed, and who was left out.
Step 1
Read & Highlight
To do
A
A new group of leaders
In May 1775, leaders from the colonies met in Philadelphia. This group was called the Second Continental Congress. Fighting with Britain had just started. The colonies did not always agree with each other. Some leaders still wanted to make peace with Britain. Others wanted to break away. Not everyone got to choose these leaders. Women, enslaved people, and many poor people had no say.
B
Building an army
In June 1775, Congress created the Continental Army. It chose George Washington to lead it. Now soldiers from different colonies had one leader. That helped the colonies work together. But the army was often short on food, guns, and money. Some colonists did not want to fight at all. By July 1776, the war was still going. No one knew who would win.
C
Asking for peace
In July 1775, Congress sent a letter to King George III. It was called the Olive Branch Petition. An olive branch is a sign of peace. The letter asked the king to help end the fighting. At the same time, Congress was paying for an army. The king refused to read the letter. In August 1775, he said the colonies were in rebellion against him.
D
Choosing independence
In early 1776, Thomas Paine wrote a short book called Common Sense. It said the colonies did not need a king. Many colonists agreed with him. On July 2, 1776, Congress voted for independence. On July 4, it approved the Declaration of Independence. The Declaration said a government should protect people's rights. But declaring independence did not make Britain agree. The war went on.
E
Who was left out
The Declaration said "all men are created equal." But it did not end slavery. It did not let women vote or lead. It used insulting words to describe Indigenous people. It did not treat them as nations with their own leaders. Leaders could agree on independence without sharing their power. Before 1776, enslaved people in Massachusetts had already asked for their freedom. They used the same words about rights that Patriots used.
F
Two views
Historians disagree about Congress. Some say rich leaders used the fight for freedom to keep their own power. Other historians point to the risks the leaders took. To Britain, declaring independence was treason. The leaders could have been hanged. Also, the Declaration's words about rights gave left-out people a way to ask for more.
Congress
a group of leaders who make decisions together
Petition
a written request
Independence
being free from another country's control
Treason
turning against your own country
Answer two questions
Step 2
Fill out the review
To do
Continental Congress · Philadelphia
Leadership Performance Review
CONFIDENTIAL Form PR-1776 · July 1776
EmployeeSecond Continental Congress
Review datesMay 1775 – July 1776
Reviewer—
Score key3 Did it · 2 Sort of · 1 Didn't
Part 1
Score each job
Give a score, pick the paragraph that proves it, and finish the sentence.
Part 2
Best and worst
1The best thing Congress did was ___ (__).
2The biggest problem was ___ (__).
Part 3
One goal for next time
Part 4
Congress answers back
Write as if you are Congress.
Reviewer signature · July 1776
for the CongressEmployee signature
Step 3
Check & turn in
How you'll be scored
Skill
3
2
1
Facts
All facts are right and from before July 1776
One small mistake
Many mistakes
Evidence
3 or more paragraph letters
2 letters
1 or none
Judging
Shows what worked and who was left out
Shows only one side well
Only praise or only blame
Form
Every part done
One part missing
Many parts missing
Out of 12. A high score or a low score can both be right if your evidence backs it up.